• +44-190-022-0819 +44-190-022-0819
  • +1-248-268-9041 +1-248-268-9041
  • +61288800241 +61288800241


Search your solution from list of 1000+ questions



The overall objective of the law in this area [Statutory Derivative Claim, s260-264] is to strike a balance between the need to uphold the majority rule principle and the need to protect minority shareholders from abuse by the majority. Expressed differently, the intention of the Law Commission was to achieve a balance between facilitating the bringing of derivative actions, where the rule in Foss v Harbottle and its exceptions were seen to create undue difficulty, and the protection of companies from too early an interference in their internal management… Considering the statutory provisions in every case is a delicate balancing act. The court must tread carefully. If it adopts a very liberal attitude, this could have the undesirable effect of encouraging frivolous claims against directors, as feared by critics. On the other hand, if it adopts a very strict approach claimants would find themselves back in the common law position where claims were severely restricted, and the very purpose of the provisions would be defeated.”


Mujih, E. The new statutory derivative claim: a paradox of minority shareholder protection: Part 2 (2012) Company Lawyer, volume 33, issue 4, pages 99-107 at page 107.


Undertake a critical evaluation of whether the process of commencing a statutory derivative claim under the Companies Act 2006 successfully achieves the balance as identified in the above quotation or whether this balance had already been achieved under the exceptions to the rule in Foss v Harbottle. ?

Word Limit: 2000 words excluding footnotes and bibliography.

Product code: Law-QA246

Download Questions

This assessment is written to focus on the importance and relevance of the duty of directors to strike a balance between protecting the interests of majority stakeholders and minority stakeholders

Related Questions in (Other)


Solution: The Journal of Helene Berr and Rue Ordener, Rue Labat 2 evidences that prove the difficulty and destructiveness that the people had to face in those four years. As mentioned by Berr (2009, p.23), in h ...


Solution: Employee communication highlights the sharing of ideas and information. In this competitive business world, information exchange is essential among employees to develop team performance effectively. m ...


Solution: As per Section 1 of the Thirteenth year plan describes about China’s two key objectives that will be accomplished if the National People’s Congress or the standing committee of this party passes t ...


Solution: (Feldman 2005) reference information extraction to be one of the weightiest pre-processing method that escalates the text mining potential significantly. Pre-processing is an essential part in informa ...


Solution: The pro forma income statement represents a trending statement that includes the probable net income value for the company considering the current growth and decline rates valid throughout the period ...


Solution: Mode is defined as the value which occurs more frequently in the data set. The mode for non-business is 82 while for business is only 59. P value can be calculated from z table . As per z table p valu ...


Solution: ABC assumes that there are different activities involved in different processes that cause costs andthe product, services, and customers are reasons for those activities. The UK customer segment is br ...


Solution: Residual earnings valuation method is used to calculate the intrinsic value of the stock based on the expected residual income of the company in the coming years. The residual income is discounted bac ...