• +44-190-022-0819 +44-190-022-0819
  • +1-248-268-9041 +1-248-268-9041
  • +61288800241 +61288800241


Search your solution from list of 1000+ questions


Joaquin was hired as a senior researcher for a medical research facility. His department has been developing a new medical device to detect HIV faster and cheaper, and the facility has promised investors a prototype would be ready in a year. However, the preliminary results have been somewhat disappointing as only 60% of the case samples have tested positive for HIV, whereas the expected sensitivity was aimed at 80%. Product development had been extended for another six months, but additional funding is needed to continue the project.

Concerned about the low true positives detected in HIV cases, senior managers decide to convene with their scientific advisors (who are under non-disclosure agreement) to determine if 60% is sufficient, if the study is adequately powered, and if there is a better way to evaluate the data. Before the meeting, Joaquin’s boss asks him to trim the data by reporting results only from certain samples, and filter out samples with low yields through observations made during meta-analysis of the clinical data.

Joaquin is uncomfortable with trimming, and argues with his boss that the scientific advisory board (SAB) should see all of their analyses, unfiltered and filtered, because it’s valuable information that could be telling them something about disease stage or test performance. His boss states that as long as they don’t lie about the numbers, there’s no harm in filtering. Joaquin counters they should show a flowchart of the numbers they started with, clinical metadata groupings, analysis methods and filtering steps so that all the information is laid out openly. In this way, the SAB has the opportunity to ask about the methods used to achieve their receiver operating curves, and better understand the clinical cohort sub-classification applied to the analysis.

The more they argue over the discussion, the more his boss is unwilling to relent. Joaquin knows that the scientific advisors will expect to see sensitivity and specificity data, ROC curves, false positives and false negatives, and figures of all unfiltered data. While the device is on its way of determining positive HIV results, it is not there yet, so he understands his boss’s reluctance to share the information.

How should Joaquin and his boss address this problem?

Product code: medical-QA430

Download Questions

Ethical dilemmas are very common. Its not that people do not understand the difference between wrong and right. they know

Related Questions in (Other)


Solution: The Journal of Helene Berr and Rue Ordener, Rue Labat 2 evidences that prove the difficulty and destructiveness that the people had to face in those four years. As mentioned by Berr (2009, p.23), in h ...


Solution: Employee communication highlights the sharing of ideas and information. In this competitive business world, information exchange is essential among employees to develop team performance effectively. m ...


Solution: As per Section 1 of the Thirteenth year plan describes about China’s two key objectives that will be accomplished if the National People’s Congress or the standing committee of this party passes t ...


Solution: (Feldman 2005) reference information extraction to be one of the weightiest pre-processing method that escalates the text mining potential significantly. Pre-processing is an essential part in informa ...


Solution: The pro forma income statement represents a trending statement that includes the probable net income value for the company considering the current growth and decline rates valid throughout the period ...


Solution: Mode is defined as the value which occurs more frequently in the data set. The mode for non-business is 82 while for business is only 59. P value can be calculated from z table . As per z table p valu ...


Solution: ABC assumes that there are different activities involved in different processes that cause costs andthe product, services, and customers are reasons for those activities. The UK customer segment is br ...


Solution: Residual earnings valuation method is used to calculate the intrinsic value of the stock based on the expected residual income of the company in the coming years. The residual income is discounted bac ...